We go through life taking many things for granted, but there is one thing so closely tied to our personal lives that to forget its importance is to commit the gravest of sins. It is a necessity we are almost completely dependent upon, comparable to our needs for food and water. It is an integral part of our daily lives–nay, our very existences–and without it, the human race becomes nothing more than soiled victims of its own gluttony. Indeed, my friends, that which I regard in such high esteem is: the gimp suit toilet paper!
Yes. Toilet paper. Paper for the toilet. Every home has at least one roll…which is usually part of a stash of rolls. And maintaining that stash tends to take precedence over other items, especially if you shop on a budget. I, being a serial starving student, have refrained from buying vegetables and fresh meats to save money for toilet paper (and because I don’t know how to cook anything unless it comes out of a box. Hamburger Helper and I are tight!). Regardless, we always have extra rolls because if we run out, the hygiene of certain body parts goes to Hell. And so does everyone’s respect for you…although, I’d actually be impressed at the parade of flies following you around. You’d be Lord of the Flies! (And there goes the last of my dignity.)
Considering what parts of us makes contact with toilet paper most often, quality is of utmost importance! It even trumps the benefits of saving money. Because while saving money can lead to some increases in wealth, low-quality toilet paper can lead to hanging bags of butt-meat, i.e., hemorrhoids!
Therefore, as president, founder, and sole member of Civilians Really Against Poor Toilet Paper (C.R.A.P.T.P.), I am deeming today the Fight Against Really Terrible TP Day (F.A.R.T.T. Day). And to commemorate the occasion, I’m going to rank some toilet paper brands in hopes that poor souls will make better choices when making their purchases.
Ratings are based on a scale of 1 to 5 of these smiling toilet paper rolls:
. I’ve ranked each brand according to the following criteria:
Touch Test: how the toilet paper feels on my butt.
Butt-Bleediness: how many times I can wipe with it before it makes my butt-skin bleed.
I know there should be more factors, but I think those are the most important ones…i.e., I’m lazy.
Kirkland Bath Tissue: 36 Rolls of 2-ply for $ 20.23
You can always tell two things about a person who shops at Costco:
-
They’ve still got 10 packs of bacon left over from the 12-pack they bought a year ago.
-
They’ve got a mountain of Kirkland Bath Tissue.
You can’t deny this; everyone knows how hard it is to fight the urge to pick up a slab of Kirkland toilet paper every time you see the price. It’s almost as difficult as ignoring those rotisserie chickens. You know, the ones that are always juicy and smelling delicious…mmm…
Ninety-six percent of the toilet paper I’ve used was Kirkland Bath Tissue. And I’m sure I’ll be saying the same thing in 40 years because my parents are Costco members, my sister is a member, I’m a member, I plan to marry a member…etc.
Touch Test


It kind of feels like Kleenex, but a tad softer. Yes, even though I’ve been using it for years, it still feels coarse on my butt. But that is probably a good thing: if I were used to the roughness, that would mean I’ve got a callous where one should not be.
Butt-Bleediness 


Expect to have some bleeding if you’re having a peanut butter poop day, but it won’t happen until the 7th wipe or so. And it doesn’t happen all the time either—unlike a certain other brand that is mentioned later on in this post. By the way, what am I eating that makes my dump that consistency anyway?
Charmin Ultra Soft: Thirty “Giant Size Rolls” for $ 19.99
I’ll be honest: I was skeptical that Charmin’s toilet paper was as amazing as the commercials made it seem. How could I be sure that the cartoon bears were genuinely happy with the softness, and not just paid actor-bears? Plus, at 67 per roll, it was too much of a luxury for my low-class butt.
But then! Costco had a coupon for Charmin Ultra Soft, which made it cheaper than the Kirkland brand! And now I’m a believer. I believe those cartoon bears!
Touch Test 




It’s thick like a paper towel, but soft like the blankie you had as a baby. I couldn’t believe such toilet paper existed! I actually sat and studied a few squares to see if there were any magical elves hiding in the layers. And there were! And they really hate the Keebler elves!
Butt-Bleediness 




Finally, a brand that doesn’t make my butt bleed! Even when I’ve got peanut butter poop! I can use up an entire roll to wipe myself clean without fear of inducing a hemorrhoid!
Ralph’s Everyday Bath Tissue: 4 rolls for 50 cents
No picture available, so I drew one of my butt cells reacting to Ralph’s toilet paper.
Sylvia’s Advice of the Day: You should never, ever tempt fate by allowing your TP rations to dwindle to the point where you are wiping your butt with the last roll. Even if you are planning to go to Costco soon, it is still not worth it. You run the risk of buying Ralph’s Everyday Bath Tissue because you kept putting off going to Costco and now you’ve got dookie booty. Don’t do it.
Touch Test 
While I knew a 12.5 cent roll was going to feel as cheap as it cost, I had no idea I just purchased butt sanding paper. Actually, sand paper is probably softer than Ralph’s Everyday Bath Tissue. Looking at the bright side: you can use the money you saved to get yourself some Preparation H.
Butt-Bleediness
How should I say this…? The first time I used it, I think I got two wipes before it broke skin. After that, every wipe—even when it wasn’t peanut butter poop— resulted in ass bleed. It was so prevalent that at one point, I thought I was dying.
Err…okay, so my list is pretty weak. But you can make it stronger by sending me some of your own toilet paper rankings! I’ll add them to the post (just remember: touch test and butt-bleediness). Oh, and as a bonus, you become automatic members of C.R.A.P.T.P.! Hooray for generosity!
Ratings By Other Awesome C.R.A.P.T.P. Members!
Scott Tissue by aznroadrunner
Touch Test
Butt-Bleediness
“Scotts sucks. Scotts is like wiping with cardboard, except that it’s really thin. It almost makes you think it’s giving you paper cuts.”
Angel Soft by gorman117
Touch Test 


Butt-Bleediness


Cottonelle by charlottegeely
Touch Test 


Butt-Bleediness


“…nicest 1-ply ever but falls apart.”